Politicians like to get into every aspect of our lives it seems. And artificial intelligence (AI) is becoming the new frontier in federal tax policy. Because of concerns about AI’s effects on workers and taxpayers, lawmakers in both parties have introduced new tax proposals.
The Democratic idea comes from Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ) who proposes a digital advertising tax, a bit tax, and an excess profits tax to fund worker training and labor insurance programs.
- Sen. Kelly deserves some credit for actually proposing to pay for new spending, and it is estimated that the taxes could raise up to $380 billion over 10 years before behavioral responses (whatever that means).
- But as most taxes are complex and easy to avoid if you know how to play the game, they would also slow economic growth. The ad tax would also partly fall on content creators, the very workers AI threatens - which doesn't seem very fair. The Tax Foundation has an excellent analysis of this proposal.
The Republican idea comes from Sen. Bernie Moreno (R-OH) who proposes a 100 percent federal tax on state and local "incentives" for large AI data centers, including sales tax exemptions for servers and chips.
- Sen. Moreno raises a fair point about data center subsidies by local governments, since many property tax abatements are non-neutral and difficult to justify, though overriding states on them is a question of federalism. That is is lawsuit waiting to happen.
- It is estimated the proposal would also tax away sales tax exemptions in at least 31 states. Those exemptions keep business inputs out of the sales tax base, as sound policy requires. And because AI chips are replaced so often, a typical sales tax would amount to an effective tax rate of about 37 percent on their return. Ouch. Another analysis of this proposal.
The bottom line is that these concerns deserve serious policy responses, but the principles have not changed: sound tax policy is neutral, simple, transparent, and stable. Narrow taxes on AI fall short of that standard, while broad-based taxes are better suited to fund public priorities. It seems like every time congress tries to micro-manage the economy, we end up paying the bill.
Add new comment